In 2014, Christopher Rawlins conducted an oral history with architect Harry Bates, which revealed Bates’ extant projects in Fire Island Pines. This late Sixties example was worse for wear: exposed wiring, scattered mechanical equipment, overgrown plantings, and a constipated infilling of a lower-level patio room, all of it slathered with Eighties mauve-and-seafoam. Fortunately, a 1971 article in House Beautiful revealed the virtues of a home created for textile designer James Patterson. Our restoration does not strive for historic purity, but it does recapture the transparency, simplicity, and love of color that marked the original home.

 

From the public walkway, the home’s deep roof overhang looms large. We clad this in vivid, up-lit tiles, a cheerful foil to the neutral cedar siding that sheathes most Fire Island homes. A grand entry stair leads to the upper level, pausing at an intermediate perch to admire the garden. The upstairs floor plan was only modestly altered. New finishes and fixtures do the heavy lifting here. The downstairs level was completely redesigned, and contains a primary bedroom, guest room, bathrooms, and a laundry room. Full-height glass doors reveal gardens to the south and the pool deck to the north, its cross-ventilated design minimizing the need for air conditioning.

 

A new pergola frames an outdoor dining room, and the fence that once tightly surrounded the deck is pushed to the perimeter, with textured detailing allowing both privacy and breezes. Scott Ahlborn’s landscape design preserves key flowering plants, mixing these with sustainable and low-maintenance companions. This marriage of architecture and landscape is fully appreciated from a new roof deck that is an irresistible place to strike a pose.

Project: A CHAT WITH HARRY BATES

Original Architect: HARRY BATES, c. 1968

Renovation Architect and Decor: RAWLINS DESIGN


Landscape Designer: SCOTT AHLBORN of JOHN MINI DISTINCTIVE LANDSCAPES

Photos:
 TOM SIBLEY

Location: FIRE ISLAND PINES, NY

1_fire_island_05_21__0565.jpg
1aHG1.jpg

HOUSE BEAUTIFUL, 1971.

1aHG2.jpg

HOUSE BEAUTIFUL, 1971.

2_fire_island_05_21__0625.jpg
Button
2b_P1020330.jpg
1a_fire_island_05_21__0150.jpg
8_fire_island_05_21__0285.jpg
2a_fire_island_05_21__0655.jpg
3_fire_island_05_21__0260.jpg
4_fire_island_05_21__0375.jpg
11-lower level.jpg
12-upper level.jpg
12a1_P1020241.jpg
5_fire_island_05_21__0525.jpg
5a_P1020238.jpg
6_fire_island_05_21__0530.jpg
7_fire_island_05_21__0535.jpg
8_fire_island_05_21__0290_1.jpg
9_fire_island_05_21__0265.jpg
10_fire_island_05_21__0315.jpg
10a_fire_island_05_21__0310.jpg
11_fire_island_05_21__0380.jpg
12_fire_island_05_21__0385.jpg
12a2_P1020242.jpg
15_fire_island_05_21__0105.jpg
15a_P1020364.jpg
13_fire_island_05_21__0300.jpg
18_fire_island_05_21__025.jpg
16_fire_island_05_21__020_1.jpg
17_fire_island_05_21__0120.jpg
18_fire_island_05_21__0245.jpg
19_fire_island_05_21__0250_1.jpg
19_fire_island_05_21__0110.jpg
19a_fire_island_05_21__0620.jpg
20_fire_island_05_21__0200.jpg
22_fire island_05_21_fill in number.jpg
21_fire_island_05_21__0280.jpg
21a_P1030557_flipped_hor.jpg
23_fire_island_05_21__0355.jpg
24_fire_island_05_21__0240.jpg
24a_P1020298.jpg
25_fire_island_05_21__0350.jpg
26_fire_island_05_21__0345.jpg
27_fire_island_05_21__0365.jpg
28_fire_island_05_21__0180.jpg
29_fire_island_05_21__0185.jpg
30_fire_island_05_21__050.jpg
31_fire_island_05_21__040.jpg
32_fire_island_05_21__0595.jpg
33_fire_island_05_21__0575.jpg
34_fire_island_05_21__0670_1.jpg
35_fire_island_05_21__0675_1.jpg
36_fire_island_05_21__0685.jpg

ALTERNATE IMAGES BELOW.

1_fire_island_05_21__0225.jpg
2_fire_island_05_21__0230.jpg
3_fire_island_05_21__0235.jpg
5_fire_island_05_21__0210.jpg
6_fire_island_05_21__0220.jpg
7_fire_island_05_21__0130.jpg
8_fire_island_05_21__0145.jpg
9_fire_island_05_21__095.jpg
10_fire_island_05_21__0395.jpg
11_fire_island_05_21__0400.jpg
12_fire_island_05_21__0405.jpg
13_fire_island_05_21__0410.jpg
14_fire_island_05_21__0275.jpg
15_fire_island_05_21__0390.jpg
16_fire_island_05_21__0545.jpg
14_fire_island_05_21__05_1.jpg
17_fire_island_05_21__0115.jpg
19_fire_island_05_21__015.jpg
20_fire_island_05_21__010.jpg
21_fire_island_05_21__0340.jpg
22_fire_island_05_21__0295.jpg
23_fire_island_05_21__0560_1.jpg
23a_fire_island_05_21__0600_1.jpg
24_fire_island_05_21__0195.jpg
25_fire_island_05_21__0330.jpg
27_fire_island_05_21__0205.jpg
26_fire_island_05_21__0320.jpg
28_fire_island_05_21__0360.jpg
29_fire_island_05_21__0370.jpg
30_fire_island_05_21__035.jpg
31_fire_island_05_21__0190.jpg
32_fire_island_05_21__0175.jpg
33_fire_island_05_21__0165.jpg
34_fire_island_05_21__030_1.jpg
35_fire_island_05_21__060.jpg
36_fire_island_05_21__065.jpg
37_fire_island_05_21__0590.jpg
38_fire_island_05_21__0690.jpg